I. Mickie James
II. Tara
III. Velvet Sky
IV. Christy Hemme
V. Taylor Wilde
Taylor Wilde only got the fifth spot because I remember watching one of her matches and her not being that bad in the ring. Velvet and Christy almost entirely got their spots off their looks and it helped Hemme that I've actually seen some of her work (not that it was all that impressive, but it's more than what I've seen from most Knockouts).